Sarah B. Wilschek, MNP
Executive Director, Congregation Ohev Beth Sholom | Youngstown, Ohio
Executive Director, Congregation Ohev Beth Sholom | Youngstown, Ohio
I'm Sarah Wilschek, a nonprofit executive who builds organizations — and the roles that lead them — from the ground up. Since April 2019, I've served as the inaugural Executive Director of Congregation Ohev Beth Sholom in Youngstown, Ohio, the first person to hold the position, where I oversee a $1.1M budget and a team of 25. There I've led a capital campaign that exceeded its goal by nearly $1M, secured nearly $1M in grant funding, and guided the congregation through a unification.
Before that, I spent seven years in leadership roles with community-based nonprofits, where I was the first community development professional and grant writer in the community I served, and designed the leadership programs that still build its pipeline today. My work runs on strategy, strong board partnership, sound operations, and relationships — with universities, civic leaders, and partners abroad. What drives all of it is my passion for strengthening communities, building relationships that last, and helping people find meaning in the work they do together.
Selected highlights
Inaugural Executive Director of Congregation Rodef Sholom (now Congregation Ohev Beth Sholom) — the first in its 159-year history
Led the 2021 unification of two synagogues from different movements into one community
Manage a $1.1 million annual operating budget and teams averaging 25 employees, plus contractors, lay leaders, and volunteers
Led a $2M+ campaign that exceeded its goal by nearly $1 million
Secured nearly $1M in federal, state, and private grants
Designed an emerging leadership program for the Youngstown Area Jewish Federation
Partnerships with Youngstown State University, the City of Youngstown, and a Partnership2GETHER relationship with Acre, Israel
President, Hillel at Kent State University (board member since 2021); national board member, NATA; co-chair for education, NATA 2022 national conference
Executive Director
Congregation Ohev Beth Sholom, Youngstown, OH
April 2019 – Present
Inaugural Executive Director in the 159-year history of Congregation Rodef Sholom (now Ohev Beth Sholom), building the role from the ground up.
Led the 2021 unification of two synagogues from different movements — navigating institutional change and cultural integration — and guided the congregation through four clergy transitions.
Partner closely with the Rabbi and have worked with eight board presidents, including through mergers. Recruit and train board members, lead volunteer teams, and established sustainable governance models.
Manage a $1.1M operating budget and a staff averaging 25, plus contractors, lay leaders, and volunteers. Redesigned the full staff structure, then redesigned it again for the merged institution.
Lead trainings on anti-bias, team building, and conflict management for staff and volunteers, and consult for other organizations.
Built partnerships with Youngstown State University, the City of Youngstown, and regional organizations; created security and accessibility frameworks that turn community needs into action.
Led $2M+ renovation campaign, exceeding goal by nearly $1M through relationship-based solicitation. Personally asked every major donor, including a $550K gift and about 20 gifts of $25K+.
Secured nearly $1M in federal, state, and private grants during the pandemic through research-informed proposals and strategic stakeholder mapping.
Project Director, Rodef Sholom Archives preservation project (Ohio Historical Records Advisory Board): wrote the grant, directed the project and YSU partnership, and authored the published article.
Community Development Manager
Jewish Community Center, Youngstown, OH
October 2017 – April 2019
Inaugural Community Development Manager in a newly created role. Designed collaborative frameworks connecting Federation agencies with secular, regional nonprofits to amplify collective impact.
Managed international Partnership2GETHER program with Acre, Israel, building cross-border community infrastructure.
Served as grant writer for the local Jewish community, composing grant applications for all Federation initiatives and translating organizational needs into funded outcomes.
Federation Program Coordinator
Youngstown Area Jewish Federation, Youngstown, OH
September 2014 – October 2017
Designed and developed an emerging leadership program to build the leadership pipeline the community needs to sustain itself.
Built interfaith coalitions across sectors to create strategic leverage for Israel advocacy and community support.
Translated the Federation's mission and vision into accessible public engagement tools through strategic communications and innovative programming.
Youth and Family Program Director
Jewish Community Center
June 2012 – September 2014
Developed and scaled cultural, educational, and social programming for youth and families; managed Camp JCC with continuous improvement methodology and staff development frameworks.
Client Service Associate
Sequoia Financial Group, Akron, OH
November 2011- May 2012
Acted as main point of contact for clients while also preparing and communicating personal financial information
Director of Broker and Client Relations
LyfeBank Ohio, Columbus, OH
April 2010- November 2011
Created a business model for employers and employees to gain access to affordable healthcare while focusing on developing public-private partnerships for individuals search for affordable healthcare
National Association for Temple Administration (NATA), Board Member
NATA, National Organization | 2022 - Present
Joined NATA Board in January 2024
Received Senior Status and Recognized for the 2023 Leadership cohort
Active participation in NATA Institute and a candidate for FTA/ FSA certification
Co-Education chairperson for the 2022 NATA Conference in Clearwater, Florida
Hillel at Kent State University, Executive Committee, Secretary
Hillel at Kent State University, Kent, OH
June 2021- Present
Advances Hillel’s mission by serving the campuses of Kent State University, The University of Akron, Hiram College, and Youngstown State University
Compass Family and Community Services, Board Member
Compass Family and Community Services, Youngstown, OH
June 2023- July 2025 (merger with another nonprofit)
Compass Family and Community Services, a local nonprofit, works tirelessly to build strong children, families, and communities. They are committed to providing essential, seamless, and comprehensive social services to all those that they serve.
Ukraine 24/7, American Proofreader and Editor
U24 Media, Ukraine
April 2022- January 2024
Volunteers with U24 media outlet in Ukraine to ensure stories from the Russian/ Ukrainian war reach American media
Directly works with Ukrainian journalists in Ukraine
Center for Holocaust and Judaic Studies Advisory Committee, Member
Youngstown State University, Youngstown, OH
September 2019- Present
Advises on strategies for the growth, improvement, and engagement of the YSU Center of Holocaust and Judaic Studies
Commission for Jewish Education, Board Member
Commission for Jewish Education, Youngstown, OH
December 2018- Present
Focuses on building a strong foundation of quality Jewish education for all Jews in our region, including oversight of Akiva Academy, MSJS, and adult lifelong Jewish education
Ohio Nonviolence Week, Executive Committee Member
Ohio Nonviolence Week, Youngstown, OH
January 2015- Present
Promotes nonviolence through community engagement, education and building community partnerships
Leadership Mahoning Valley, Class Coordinator
Leadership Mahoning Valley, Youngstown, Ohio
October 2017- May 2018
Identified and trained to become a future community leader for the Mahoning Valley
Woman of Impact
Dandelion Inc.
January 2024
Recognized as a woman who is inclusive, supportive, and dedicated to making a positive impact on the world.
Senior Status with the National Association for Temple Administration (NATA)
NATA, National Affiliation
April 2023
Demonstrated professional excellence in the field of executive director leadership.
Completed multiple levels of education and training to meet ongoing standards
2023 Women's Hall of Fame Nominee
League of Women Voters of Greater Youngstown
March 2023
Identified as a woman who has empowered, educated, engaged, and advocated for the people in the Mahoning valley; who has made an enduring local impact; and who has fought to uphold the values of democracy
12 Under 36: Members of the Tribe Award Nominee
Cleveland Jewish News, Northeast Ohio
August 2021
Recognized as a rising Jewish leader in the Northeast Ohio community
National Association for Temple Administration (NATA)
NATA, National Affiliation
April 2019- Present
Professional organization for those who serve synagogues as executives, administrators, or managers. Active in the Cleveland and Pittsburgh networks as well as nationwide conversations and conferences
Athena Award Nominee
Youngstown/ Warren Regional Chamber of Commerce, Youngstown, OH
April 2019
Nominee for the 27th Athena Award which recognizes women who strive toward the highest level of professional accomplishment
Mahoning Valley Young Professionals 25 Under 35
Mahoning Valley Young Professionals, Youngstown, Ohio
December 2018
Nominated and honored as a leading young professional across all business arenas in the Mahoning Valley
Mid-Career Fellowship Recipient, Gratz College
Gratz College, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
October 2017- December 2018
Identified as a future leader of the American Jewish community and mentored by national Jewish leaders
Building and Creating Partnerships
Create mutually beneficial, sustainable relationships between partner organizations and individuals
Governance
Works with multiple boards to implement best governance practices
Create effective and efficient board relationships
Educate on the role of board members and the responsibilities associated with the titles
Grant Writing
Successful grant writer for local, state, and federal grant opportunities
Raised nearly $1M in grant funds
Commnunication
Clear and strong written and verbal communication skills
Focuses on storytelling and aligning mission with values
Organizational Management
Creates functional, efficient, and healthy organizational atmospheres
Leadership Development
Assists in training in areas of excellence, including SRE, JEDI, and REDI
Trains in leadership styles
Identifies and prepares future organizational leaders
Media Relations
Strong communications background
Healthy relationships with media partners
Strategic Planning/ Visioning
Provides visioning and planning sessions for strategic organizational growth
Managing Change and Transition
Assists with organizational change management
Focuses on best practice implementation
Fundraising
Successful fundraiser
Provides enthusiastic energy toward future and sustainable projects
Gratz College, Philadelphia, PA
Masters of Science in Nonprofit Management
Additional Certification in Jewish Communal Service Obtained December 2018
The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH
Bachelor of Science in Business Administration
Specialization: Human Resource Management Obtained June 2010
Alpha Epsilon Phi Sorority Member, Rho Chapter